Independant Push Notification (GSF Independet)
After switching to Lineageos without a Google Playstore, I am unable to receive push notifications from protonmail, because it relies on the google service framework.
If you could keep an independent push notification functionality, like telegram foss or wechat, it's much appreciated.
-
PrivacyPlease
commented
As a visionary paid plan customer for several years, I'm disappointed to witness some easily-fixable persistant red flags...
Most people looking for privacy or basic ethics despises Google for good reasons. It's a simple fact.
Why keep relying on Google Play to allow notifications on the most important app of the Proton ecosystem ?
It's even harder to understand when privacy-respecting alternatives already exist.
I know you can do better and I'm sure you could bring a lot more trust with little fixes like this one.
A loving customer that want to continue its privacy journey with you ;)
-
V
commented
Stop relying on google for push notifications. You guys are meant to be a privacy oriented service so act like one. This is a repost of the issue which has been going on for way too long.
-
V
commented
Still waiting for this feature. At this point, I think they have forgotten about it.
-
Max
commented
I agree with all the other comments this is such a critical feature
-
anonymous
commented
Many people here blame Proton for not implementing independent push notifications. But honestly, I just scratch my head when looking at the top feature requests with thousands of votes which at best fall under the category "nice to have". This one so crucial has just 80+ votes as of Nov 24 after several years of polling...
Tyranny of the majority...
Nevertheless, as a privacy focused company this should have been on their agenda even without any feature request. -
user
commented
They want to be the go-to privacy app, but depend on Google push notifications? When I entered a feature request, their support staff was the most unhelpful and dismissive person I have ever talked to.
-
Taha
commented
I completely agree with the need for independent push notifications in Proton Products. Relying on Google Services Framework (GSF) hinders user privacy and limits functionality for those who prefer not to use Google apps.
I prefer having a background job that would check for new emails now an then than having continuous notification delivery tunneled through google servers.
-
Bob Dobolina
commented
This is an important feature I would like to see implemented.
-
[Deleted User]
commented
This is a must and basic need for a privacy app.
-
Anonymous
commented
This feature is a must in order to be conpletely free from Google!!!
-
Imran
commented
It's ridiculous how long people have been requesting this. Battery life should no longer be an issue now that UnifiedPush exists (and distributor apps like Ntfy.sh work perfectly).
-
Axel
commented
I have, and will only ever have, a deGoogled phone (I use LineageOS) without Google Play Services.
I need a sound notification for incoming mail that is private just like Protonmail emails.
Thanks -
Soheil
commented
It's crazy that this is still not fixed in the official app, specially as there is a workaround that requires a third party app (I don't need to say how bad it is, do not install the workaround please)
I want to see background synchronization being an option on all versions of the app. Should be fairly easy to warn the user about battery consumption (which is negligible honestly, no more than Play services). But unified Push must be implemented as well. It is very easy to implement and doesn't even have the battery consumption downside.
I'm so excited just thinking about Unified Push for ProtonMail.
-
Anonymous
commented
"Privacy by default" it says on the top of the page, mockingly, as I am required to run Google Playservices on GrapheneOS to actually recieve my emails.
-
S
commented
I would totally need this, because I use Android without Google Services and therefore without the ability to receive Google Push Notifications.
A setting for regularly polling for new mails or getting updates via a websocket connection would be great.
But the ability to trigger a webhook would also do the job for me. -
Mike
commented
UnifiedPush exists and is being used by other apps. There's no reason to stay with Google anymore. I want to degoogle!
-
[Deleted User]
commented
Do the developers not read the suggestions on this site?
-
Mahi
commented
Bruh. We use ProtonMail the NUMBER ONE reason being avoding google. And they do these kinds of shenanigans.
You know what, they don't have a public friendly issue tracker, they don't accept pull requests, they don't publish their services on f-droid. And now this.
I've recently listened to Techlore podcast, & it seemed like Andy's no different than any other corporate sc@mmers.
Believe me, PM looks like a FOSS service with GPLv3 but it technically isn't, because it doesn't follow OSF standards. -
frnm lanm commented
You ask HOW CAN WE IMPROVE PROTON MAIL
But you are obviously virtue-signalling and don't actually care
This GSF thing is many years old. FFS people, we are shedding dipshits like gobble and crapple and microslop, people have had enough so fix your **** or we move somewhere else -
frnm lanm commented
Its now 2023 and proton has not resolved this yet??!
I will be letting my subscription go to zero and finding another provider of secure mail and VPN, this is unacceptable and ridiculous.
Why would anyone use ProtonVPN or mail if it requires GSF?