Reply from Simple Login Alias
If an email is received via forwarding from a simple login alias, I want the ability to reply to the sender through the proton email web client without leaking my proton email address. Currently, email replies originate from my proton email. Emails received from a simple login forwarding alias should default to the simple login alias in the 'Sent From' field if I reply to the email.
-
nic
commented
The possibility seems to exist but far to commplicated for classic users
And what about not having to create an account(reverse or simplelogin)?
Just use that alias immediatly (without doing anything else, in the "from" area when sending an email
Just maybe to have the possibility when creating the alias to say
1) if it will be used to send emails (so it will automaticaly appears in the "from" area when sending an email
2) the displayed name that will see the receiver of the email -
nic
commented
The possibility seems to exist but far to commplicated for classic users
And what about not having to create an account?
Just use that alias immediatly (without doing anything else, in the "from" area when sending an email
Just maybe to have the possibility when creating the alias to say
1) if it will be used to send emails (so it will automaticaly appears in the "from" area when sending an email
2) the displayed name that will see the receiver of the email -
Dennis
commented
Hey pat, What you said only applies to forwarding emails, since you are forwarding the mail not your alias.
Apart from that, your email is shielded.
When you reply, you reply to the simplelogin address which forwards your email. Basically SimpleLogin sits as postman during the process.
Try doing this with a test account. See what the sender sees.
-
Pat Bloomfield
commented
I’d like to suggest an improvement to how aliases are handled.
Current behaviour
When I send an email using a SimpleLogin reverse alias (e.g. pat.test@slmail.me), the recipient correctly sees the alias in the From field. However, when I forward or reply to that same message, ProtonMail automatically changes the From field back to my real ProtonMail address (pat.example@proton.me).
Why this matters
This creates an unintended privacy leak. The main reason many of us use aliases is to protect our real email address, but any forward or reply can expose it.
Suggested improvement
When replying to or forwarding a message that was originally sent via an alias, ProtonMail should default to (or at least remember and offer) that same alias in the From field.
This small change would make the alias feature significantly more robust and privacy-preserving.
Thanks for considering this request — I believe many users who rely on aliases for privacy would really appreciate it. -
Roel Feeney commented
Does it work without an internet connection? Once the page has fully loaded, you can use this online age tool entirely offline all calculations run locally in your browser with no internet required. https://agefinder.org/#general Fonts and icons load from external CDNs and may fall back to system defaults offline, but the core calculation works without any connection.
-
Nico
commented
If I receive an email through my alias, then reply to it, it's fine as it uses the reverse proxy.
BUT, if I reply to my reply, then it shows my actual email in the "-------- Original Message --------" part. -
Peter
commented
This is definitely NOT complete . . . or there's some hidden setup required. Needs to be automatic and seamless.
-
GDID Anon
commented
Reply from Simple Login Alias
If an email is received via forwarding from a simple login alias, I want the ability to reply to the sender through the proton email web client without leaking my proton email address. Currently, email replies originate from my proton email. Emails received from a simple login forwarding alias should default to the simple login alias in the 'Sent From' field if I reply to the email. -
User
commented
How is this completed?
When replying to emails sent to alias, it still shows the main email in the "from" field.
Also, in the "Identity and addresses" settings, while there's explicit mention of aliases ("Use the different types of email addresses and aliases offered by Proton."), the aliases are nowhere to be seen.
What is this user experience, please? It's obvious that if using an alias, sending emails should show, or at least allow to select the alias in the "from" field.
This has also been pointed out for 2 years, as per this thread.
-
Terri
commented
This is still happening!! What gives?! If it's 'really' sending thru my alias why does it load with my mail email addy that I'm trying to hide? Why do I supposedly have "10" aliases that are still useless when I reply?? What's up with that? This is the reason I'm only paying for the basic features. Why pay for more if the ones I'm using aren't working? Even if I have 'unlimited aliases' if they're useless when I reply, why pay for more useless aliases? I see where some have said to enable "Reverse Alias Replacement" for Simple Login setting. I have been to my settings but have not seen any such permission.
-
uvC
commented
It does work for SimpleLogin contacts but this isn't immediately visible in my proton mail client it shows my actual proton address as the sender.
Is there a way to have it show the alias? -
Geoffrey
commented
If I well understood… Just check the Simple Login settings and enable "Reverse Alias Replacement". That should make the job…
-
Michael D commented
Absolutely. I was thinking about this the other day. The "Hide My Email" aliases are pretty much useless if you are required to reply back. They get your real email. Bit of a joke when you think about it. It is only useful if you are certain it is a one-way communication.
-
Ro
commented
Could proton provide a updated tutorial on this? I notice a lot of spam in the spam folder and a notice to get simple login a third party company and I would prefer that proton manage all the tunneling instead. should I use today what extension simple login or proton pass? I want my clients to know my e-mail and not scammers asking for fake invoice payments. thank you
-
steven
commented
The answer you sent actualy from your proton email don't go for your destinate adress bu to a simple login alias, who understand you want send an answer with your simple login alias to original adresse of your destinate.
This feature it'd already on live, you can test with your personal mailbox