My use case: comparing a long device manual against a tender spec and listing every unmet requirement — verbatim, word for word. Standard compliance/tender work.
Lumo does not even start and the context is done...
Ran the identical task on a free Gemini account: both PDFs uploaded, full point-by-point analysis, no compaction, no lost fidelity.
For fairness: I get Proton's privacy angle — zero-access encryption, no training on your data — that's why I picked Lumo. But privacy doesn't require a small context window, and it doesn't excuse such limited usability.
Paid ~xx$/year for a tool that couldn't finish the job a free competitor completed without blinking. Filed a complaint with support.
Not anti-Proton, I'm a paying customer across the ecosystem. But for long-document professional work: it's not there yet.
Conny
My use case: comparing a long device manual against a tender spec and listing every unmet requirement — verbatim, word for word. Standard compliance/tender work.
Lumo does not even start and the context is done...
Ran the identical task on a free Gemini account: both PDFs uploaded, full point-by-point analysis, no compaction, no lost fidelity.
For fairness: I get Proton's privacy angle — zero-access encryption, no training on your data — that's why I picked Lumo. But privacy doesn't require a small context window, and it doesn't excuse such limited usability.
Paid ~xx$/year for a tool that couldn't finish the job a free competitor completed without blinking. Filed a complaint with support.
Not anti-Proton, I'm a paying customer across the ecosystem. But for long-document professional work: it's not there yet.