Why Should I?
My feedback
4 results found
-
18,275 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment Why Should I?
supported this idea
·
-
2 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment Why Should I?
commented
Hell No! Do NOT implement something this blindingly ignorant! The arguments in favor are profoundly dishonest.
For the benefit of the whoever posted the feature request.
#1 How would protonmail classify files if they're already encrypted without protonmail possessing a master decryption key? Defeats the purpose of protonmail and advances the agenda of those against end-to-end encrypted email - which exists for a reason.
#2 If child porn is found, in most nations the service provider is legally obligated to inform the proper authorities ( but you already knew that )
Pedofiles also breathe air. That doesn't mean everyone is obligated to stop breathing or obligated to report every breath for inspection by their local authorities. Even ' for the sake of the children ".
Based on your idea, I think Apple I-cloud services would be a better fit for you. There, each file uploaded to the cloud is first compared to a database provided by the US FBI in real time. Meaning at any given instant, the same agency has a list of files being uploaded into the I-cloud. Perfect for persecuting whistleblowers and leakers. Do you see the problem with the concept? You're free to use Apple I-cloud to your heart's content.
-
32 votesWhy Should I?
supported this idea
·
-
9 votesWhy Should I?
shared this idea
·
Ditto. I had a sudden need for a collaboration feature in ProtonDrive. At this time the feature doesn't exist in Proton, so I'm passing over an upgrade to the ProtonDrive account in favor of a cloud service that does offer the collaboration function.
The feature request remains unfulfilled since the December 2016, despite the number of votes 3X more than the next runner-up. Which I take to imply that it's not possible within the current Proton security framework. Else the feature would have been implemented ages ago.