#2 is very important.

As usual Proton releases a feature that’s only half-baked! Just look at Apple’s “Hide my email” feature for how integration should really work instead of Proton’s kludgy style. IMHO, Proton has provided NO user friendly integration between SimpleLogin email addresses and Proton Mail apps (mobile apps integration is nil).

Goal: Easily send email from an alias based on recipient domain.

For example, in Proton Pass there is a login item with an alias as the user name. The login item also a website "https://login.example.com".

Consider adding a shortcut to create the reverse alias when sending an email to "sales@example.com".

This can help people remember to create the reverse alias and continue hiding their real email.

Displaying the calculated from email address in the "From" field when composing the email will improve clarity.

Waiting on #2 eagerly. Good to see #1 and #3 completed.

I would argue #3 is not completed.

I use SimpleLogin, not Proton Pass, for passwords because Pass is not yet comparable in features to KeepPass (I'm looking forward to this changing). Pass aliases do not show up in SL and using the side panel to generate aliases would mean i would have to manage my aliases across two platforms. Not to mention SL aliases are still more feature rich than Pass aliases.
Additionally, from the side panel, I actually am looking to generate reverse aliases, not incoming aliases. (Most people are trying to email out to someone when using your mail app, not trying to give someone their contact details).

I love the great work and the continual torrent of upgrades Proton is always providing, but please don't get over zealous when marking this feature as completed. :-)

I wouldn't mind paying more to use SimpleLogin but I do need the ability to send emails from the aliases that I created within Proton Pass. Without that, I cannot initiate conversations to companies without using their own "contact me" page. I cannot really use SimpleLogin now as it would not sync with the aliases I have within Proton Pass.

Yes, this sloud be a great ! some sites recgnize user by his personal email registered and if i write as sender from a different email (alias is not permitted) they do not reply and do not recognize user...

This. CRITICAL FEATURE.

@Klaus Heissler: Have you enabled "Reverse Alias Replacement" in your SimpleLogin settings?
https://www.reddit.com/r/Simplelogin/comments/qfh1ka/we_have_improved_a_lot_the_reverse_alias/

I'm not sure if it works 100% of the time, but it seems to generally work well for me (I don't need to do anything and SimpleLogin automatically substitutes my actual ProtonMail address with the SimpleLogin alias).

When answering to an email, ProtonMail automatically includes previously exchanged messages. And when recipients have a look to them, they can see the original ProtonMail address of my account.

ProtonMail should replace my sender address by the alias address in all emails I send.

We should also be able to find them quickly and be able to copy them in the Mail app! Right now, I have to go to Settings and then to My addresses to copy my aliases. It should be better integrated.

While I used simplelogin before proton bought then, I agree integration is needed. I have allot of aliases and it would be great to more control and such from the protonmail interface.

I’m new to both proton and SimpleLogin but using it extensively to have unique aliases for the majority of my logins. The two services still feel disjointed and any effort to better integrate them is appreciated.

It took me hours of experimentation to figure out how to send emails from a hide-my-address alias. I finally stumbled across the trick. A hide-my-address alias is the only kind of address I would give out. This should work the same as Thunderbird aliases.

Edit: Today I spent several more hours getting hide-my-address aliases to work with my own domain name. Parts of the process are extremely messy, but do work. But there were lots of undocumented steps found by trial and error and figuring out various error messages. Mammoth kludges.

Adding my votes

2. Is essential for intuitive ux ,got really confused replying to mail from alias

This feature would be amazing, hopefully it would also work with the proton bridge.

This would allow me to send emails via Thunderbird as identities(https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/using-identities) directly.

Any forwarded email to a proton inbox would no longer require having the reply-to replaced with a generated alias. Since you would be able to send it (seemingly) directly to them from that alias.

This would also fix calendar invites: https://github.com/simple-login/app/discussions/1741

This is absolutely fundamental!

If I'm shopping for insurance and need to contact three firms, then I should be able to compose a new email and then:

generate new SL alias (and choose the SL alias mailboxe(s)) the contact should belong to; or, select an existing SL alias the contact should belong to. At which point, the reverse-alias is autogenerated in the Proton email and added to the TO field.

A proton user should not have to use two applications to achieve this workflow with SL now under Proton.

similar idea here; https://protonmail.uservoice.com/forums/284483-proton-mail/suggestions/46160269-send-from-alias-address

Also, not sure if this belongs in Email or Pass, or both: https://protonmail.uservoice.com/forums/284483-proton-mail/suggestions/47763086-sync-labels-between-proton-mail-and-simplelogin

As https://github.com/ProtonMail/WebClients/issues/316#issuecomment-1928589036 states:

> Regardless of how it appears to the user, I'd integrate with addy.io under the hood rather than SimpleLogin.