General Ideas
162 results found
-
Remove your CEO
Proton cannot treat its engineers like this. You cannot keep my business if you have an internal culture of fear. You cannot recklessly rush to AI. I joined Proton - and brought my entire family here - because I believe in slow-built quality. Your CEO has poisoned the well. We do not want him. He cannot be trusted. He will resign, or I will move all of our accounts somewhere else.
18 votesUservoice is for feature and functionality requests.
-
quand faites vous un proton de gestion de projet?
un proton avec les posibilités de Project
2 votesAs per the rules on the front page please raise ideas in English. Use a translation tool if that is needed.
-
Remove anything and everything that was written with AI and remove Lumo
Remove all AI.
And can someone slap Andy Yen please?2 votesUservoice is a space to share, comment, and upvote ideas for new services, features, and check status updates.
This idea is not for a new service or feature, and has therefore been removed.
-
Andy should step down
There was an issue with 3000+ votes for Andy Stepping down.
It was the most upvoted UserVoice issue, but now it's gone. Here is the archive.org link: https://web.archive.org/web/20261031004517/https://protonmail.uservoice.com/forums/945460-general-ideas/suggestions/51867423-andy-yen-steps-aside
Where is it now? Do we have to agentically flood UserVoice or you gonna keep the issue up?
In any case:
Andy is an AI-pilled douche scumbag
Proton users choose Proton because it was perceived as less douchebagy than Big Tech. No longer.
If you want your users' trust back, the only thing you can do is fire the CTO and the CEO.
If this post goes down, I guarantee you it…
19 votesUservoice is a space to share, comment, and upvote ideas for new services, features, and check status updates.
This idea is not for a new service or feature, and has therefore been removed.
-
Commission an external, independent audit
The recent media coverage about toxic management, the prioritisation of AI, and the neglect of privacy as a core principle are truly worrying with regard to Proton's future. The reason most, if not all, customers choose Proton is because of their promise to always put privacy first. So in light of these revelations, Proton should commission an external, independent audit of its management culture and the principles guiding its strategy, and take action to get back on track and guarantee privacy in its products, as well as foster a healthy corporate culture where concerns can be raised without being shut…
12 votesUservoice is for raising new features or product ideas; due to this, this is being declined. If you have features or product ideas you'd like to request, feel free to raise them or vote on other people's submissions.
-
Proton needs to breed river *****
As a paying customer who has been reading this forum with great attention lately, I have identified one measure that is supported by strong evidence from East Asia, costs little, and is guaranteed to leave the community content: Proton should breed river ***** and distribute them to the community, free of charge.
The evidence. Across East Asia, communities with abundant river ***** are famously content. Each autumn the harvest arrives, ***** are exchanged as gifts, and for weeks on end nobody asks an awkward question. Everyone's hands are busy and everyone's mouth is full, and the effect on community harmony…
2 votesPlease use this space to raise product and feature requests.
-
Andy Yen must resign immediately
Andy Yen and Bart Butler must resign immediately, and be replaced by people who understand that AI slop is not compatible with security.
5 votesThank you for taking the time to share this. UserVoice is intended for feature requests about Proton's products, so this idea is being closed. -
Moderate Community Discord with Proton Staff
I was banned from Proton’s Discord community after objecting to repeated abusive and abrasive messages from a member named Salty. Many people had reportedly raised concerns about this person, but after I finally responded in anger, I was the one silenced and banned.
I withdrew my financial support as a result. Since then, I’ve had several experiences that have left me feeling Proton treated me unfairly, perhaps because I spoke out.
If Proton wants to maintain a credible reputation, it should have employees oversee its social media communities rather than relying on moderators who appear to tolerate abusive conduct, apply…
2 votesUservoice is for feature and product requests; as such, this is being declined.
-
Don't delete posts you don't like
Deleting posts with thousands of upvotes which you don't like, e.g the post calling for consequences for your CEO's actions, is unforgivable.
Your reputation is all you have.
17 votesThank you for taking the time to share this. This UserVoice space is for product suggestions about Proton's services, so this idea does not fit here and is now closed. -
"AI" is the Antithesis of What Paying Users Are Here For
"AI" is the antithesis of what paying users are here for. Don't let Andy Yen's AI Psychosis take Proton down the same path as Tesla and Twitter. We are here to get away from the Tech Bro ******** and the sloppification of the web.
We've all uprooted ourselves once already to make the move to Proton — we'll do it again if you don't change course.
7 votesThank you for taking the time to share this. UserVoice is intended for feature requests about Proton's products, so we are closing this idea. -
WHATSAPP just started feeding me ADS! Can't Proton do Meta one better?
Proton has everything except a chatting app! Just today, my "private, non-ad" WhatsApp started shoving ADS at me! It seems to me that PROTON can do WhatsApp so much better than Meta can ever do! As one of the original creators of WhatsApp once said, I am now the PRODUCT, now that ads are in my WhatsApp world. PROTON, HELP US!
2 votesWe're sorry to hear that. Please use this forum to raise product and feature requests.
-
Proton AI Coding Shift
It would be foolish to think that companies are not going to leverage AI as a tool for specific coding or other internal tasks. AI can be a force multiplier, but only when used correctly. However, all of the good companies I have worked directly with are not firing this out of the tube with such veracity.
Humans always need to come first. First in decision making. First in Quality Assurance. First in coding decisions. AI is not going to replace humans, nor should we be trying to drive everything in that direction. And all your customers agree.
If Proton…
45 votesThank you for sharing this idea. UserVoice is intended for feature requests about Proton's products, so this submission is being closed. -
Replace paying customers with LLMs. Replace CEO with LLM
Hear me out, I know they don't make any money yet, but we should really think about pushing for a bubble-shaped business plan, or like a circle-jerk-shaped business. All we need is to figure out how to get these LLMs making money, then we'll use that money to pay for proton services, like proton mail, drive, etc! It's an ingenious business plan, and we should implement it immediately. Anyways, this is a good time to let you all know that I'm cancelling my subscription and returning to paper mail. You'll be fine. It's you, not me. Good luck!
6 votesThank you for taking the time to share this. UserVoice is intended for feature requests about Proton's products, so this idea is being closed to keep the board focused. -
Get rid of Uservoice
You are a privacy focused company so you ask for improvements via Uservoice Inc - a US company!!!!!
To be able to use this feature to get the features I really want you have me use a US company, to give them our IP address, email address and names. This is an awful choice - I thought you were better and principled on privacy.
Really disappointed - get rid of them and get or build a system yourselves in Swiss or EU.
Steve AG
(This and the lack of shared mailboxes is pushing me off this platform.
5 votesPlease use this platform for feature and product requests.
-
Proton needs employee representatives
Tuta has a works council in Hanover. Proton sites needs to have employee representations too. That helps to manage conflicts between the Proton management and the employees. If sufficiently countervailing power is given to employee representatives, the members of Proton's top management can focus on their strengths (without them Proton wouldn't exist) and even might not have to change their attitudes too much.
Remark: It is the task of employees to found works councils. Unions and works councils are different things. Unionizing is not required to found works councils, but it can help.
17 votesThank you for taking the time to share this suggestion. UserVoice is intended for feature requests about Proton's products, so this idea is being closed. -
Ban chatbot usage instead of worshipping it
I will take a fast and stable lean product developed slowly anytime over a slow and bloated product developed hastily.
12 votesThank you for sharing this suggestion. This space is intended for feature requests about Proton's products, so we are closing this idea. -
Prioritize security and retention of experienced employees over "speed"
Like most people, I switched to Proton because I do NOT want to be part of the whole tech bro eco system. I want reliable, safe, stable and private mail and password services. I don't want shiny new features that nobody needs. I don't want AI to draft my documents, write my code, build my webpages - and I MOST DEFINITELY don't want it to write the code to my mail and password services!
As a senior software engineer, I know quite well how much damage AI currently does to the code base of any company using it. So shove…
28 votesThank you for taking the time to share this. UserVoice is intended for requests about Proton's products, so we are closing this idea. -
ISO 45001 certification for OHS (Occupational Health and Safety) management at Proton
Existing feature: Due to legal requirements I am sure that Proton already has a professional OHS management. Right?
However, because of the recent leadership blunders at Proton, I got curious to understand how Proton manages psychological health and safety at work (ISO 45003) of their 700+ employees. Unsurprisingly, like most competitors, Proton's OHS management isn't ISO 45001 certified. This means that Proton probably doesn't take care of the mental health of their employees better than their competitors. Put simply, as for the employees' OHS, Proton doesn't make any difference to how big tech competitors of Proton with their sociopathic leaders…
9 votesThank you for taking the time to share this suggestion. UserVoice is intended for feature requests about Proton's products, so this idea is being closed. -
Freedom for people, not machines.
Technology and algorithms must serve people, instead of limiting their free will, dignity and subjectivity.
19 votesThank you for sharing your thoughts. UserVoice is intended for feature requests about Proton's products, so we are closing this idea. -
Bar the use of LLMs for all code, tests, and documentation
LLMs are a destructive choice for coding, testing, and documentation. They are environmentally, ethically, and clinically bad for everyone except those profiting from the hype. They have no place in a secure, ethical, quality coding environment. Bar them from all contributions immediately as nearly all of your customers would want.
23 votesThank you for taking the time to share this suggestion. UserVoice is intended for feature requests about Proton's products, so we are closing this idea.
- Don't see your idea?