Andy Yen, CEO, should step down completely
It is unacceptable that Proton is going the AI Psychosis route because of the C-Suite when it's against everything their customer base wants.
Proton is actively going against their market and customer base with this decision, and this should be enough to fire and have Andy Yen and any other C-suite member that agrees with the plan to resign immediately.
-
Rapunzel
commented
Chat Guy, will you keep your subscription if Andy Yen steps down?
What should happen after Andy Yen steps down? -
Chat Guy
commented
Unacceptable. Please step down.
-
Rapunzel
commented
Tony the Geek, you cancelled your subscription because you are sad what's become of Proton. This is not about "Andy Yen, CEO, should step down completely" anymore. Is the damage done by Andy Yen irreversible even if he would step down?
https://www.reddit.com/r/ProtonPublic/comments/1xmnqxa/comment/19s2owoqhd21u/ is a "chronology of what has lead to this communications clusterfuck", concluding "that Proton is currently in quite the pickle financially and if you have to survive, this usually brings out the worst in people. And yes, implying you can tamper with core safety - your major selling point - just to be faster is inexcusable and will not help your company survive if people are leaving for exactly this reason." I am not sure whether "Andy Yen, CEO, should step down completely" solves the problem, which is not just Andy Yen's approach to using AI.
-
YonYonson
commented
I have waited to see how Proton would handle this situation and after seeing their efforts to misrepresent, deflect, and astroturf, I have lost complete and utter faith in the company as it is. I have cancelled my subscription and well move elsewhere just as I did when I came to Proton. I wanted to leave scummy companies then and I still do now. I feel like many users fall into this same camp.
Getting rid of the scummy leadership will only the beginning of regaining my trust. Trust is what I was paying you for and you have proven that you are currently incapable of trustworthy or good-faith behavior. I genuinely hope to see this change.
-
Tony the Geek
commented
Rap, there are countless other alternatives, all of which deserve a new thread and voting for that suggestion directly. Stop trying to highjack the one that unequivocally states that Any Yen should step down immediately. You expressed your dissent, got your one vote and now can kindly stfu or start your own thread with an alternative
-
Rapunzel
commented
Tony the Geek, are there no alternatives to Andy Yen stepping down completely?
-
Tony the Geek
commented
Rap, How about focusing on the subject of this suggestion instead of repeatedly posting what should be its own thread
-
Rapunzel
commented
Tony the Geek, thank you for your empathy. But I prefer to focus on Proton.
-
Tony the Geek
commented
Rapunzel likes the sound of their own voice. Maybe get some help with your main character syndrome
-
Rapunzel
commented
I don't know yet what's become and what will become of Proton.
-
Tony the Geek
commented
Cancelled my subscription. Sad what's become of proton
-
Rapunzel
commented
Kat blu, thank you. To you and anon: I proposed three improvements - see https://www.reddit.com/r/ProtonPublic/comments/1xoit1u/comment/19s8gpdk9m6ys/ - not only because of the improvements themselves, but also to see how Proton's top management deals with these proposals. Especially if the CEO, the CTO and the other C-suit members have works-council-phobias like the top management of any "normal" big tech company and if they have issues with transparency and sharing power with employees, then Proton isn't the special company (anymore) which Proton's customers thought is.
I pay for performance (privacy and reliability in the 1st place) and for culture (which does not only affect the employees but also is required for that performance). If that culture softly and then suddenly vanishes away, it might not be necessary that I cancel my subscription - simply because Proton and its business model itself might be vanishing away. I don't know whether the vanishing of the CEO and CTO can prevent that.
-
anon
commented
And the CTO
-
Kat blu
commented
I agree with Diego that a big apology is due to his employees and to us, customers.
To Rapunnzel: probably would be a good idea to unionize and get more strength among them, but I still believe the first step from A.Y should be to provide a valid proof that he understands people concerns and wants to move away from the AI idea or move away completely from Proton and let someone else do the job. He can play with Lumo, after have done serious work with Proton and without mixing the two together. -
Rapunzel
commented
Thank you, Diego, for not responding like a bot. I agree with you. And Proton should stop the hemorrhage and somehow mitigate this PR disaster quickly. At present, I am pausing moving anything to Proton, because I don't know how Proton will proceed. For example, I stopped migrating from other authenticator apps to Proton's authenticator.
-
Diego
commented
It is astonishing now A.Y. is shooting himself in his foot (or at the very least, shooting in his company's one) by misreading Proton users' motivations. Employee representations and unionizing might be a good way to counter leadership's shortcomings, but at this point, bolder moves [a clear, unequivocal apology to Proton consumers and employees? A public commitment to keep privacy and security as the absolute priority over uncontrolled IA-powered growth(profit)-seeking? A.Y. resignation or eviction? All of the above?] seem unavoidable if Proton wants to stop the hemorragy and somehow mitigate this PR disaster.
-
Rapunzel
commented
JD, also Proton's employees got some revenue from you.
(1) What do you think about implementing employee representations (works councils) at Proton?
(2) Could transparent sustainability reporting help to recover your confidence in Proton's ethos and professionalism -
JD commented
I recently renewed my 2 year visionary plan so Proton has got my money, but it has lost my confidence in it's ethos and professionalism. I feel like ******.
Andy Yen has got his revenue, I don't think he will ever regain my trust (or future revenue).
-
Rapunzel
commented
The OHS (Occupational Health and Safety) department of Proton needs to analyze the behavior of Andy Yen and the other C-suite members. As for preventing hazardous mental stress, ISO 45003 could help. Regrettably, Proton isn't certified for ISO 45001 yet. Within the ISO 45000 series, ISO 45003 is a guidance standard. It cannot be certified, but independent certification and assessment bodies (ideally selected by the employees) could audit Proton's alignment with ISO 45003 principles. And some members of a works council should be enabled to conduct internal audits (ISO 19011).
-
Rapunzel
commented
Tridy, would establishing employee representations at Proton be among the necessary changes addressing your concerns? Henry, would that be the right thing here? Tuta has a works council in Hanover. Google has a European Works Council (EWC) including Swiss and UK workers. Founding and operating works councils is a measure that can be taken by Proton employees at all Proton sites in Europe.